A viral baseball moment shows why piling on isn’t the answer.
No, Not Everything Was Better Yesterday
How nostalgia tricks us into thinking the past was better than the present
She didn’t commit a crime. She didn’t hurt anyone. But the internet came for her anyway. By now, you’ve probably seen the clip. A Phillies fan in Miami, caught in the middle of a scrum, ripped a home run ball away from another fan. She marched over with full “I’d like to see the manager” vibes, grabbed it back, and the crowd reacted.
Within minutes, the video was everywhere. Social media lit up, and everyone had a take. Some said the guy should never have given the ball up. Others said she had no right. Memes exploded. Then came the labels: She’s a liberal. She’s MAGA. One baseball suddenly turned into a culture war.
The Marlins tried to cool things down with free swag for the family. The Phillies went further, arranging a meet-and-greet with Harrison Bader, the player who hit the ball. That should have been the end.
But the internet had another mission. Find Phillies Karen.
Amateur sleuths went digging. Names started circulating. One woman, Cheryl Richardson-Wagner, was falsely identified. She had to jump on Facebook to set the record straight:
“I’m NOT the crazy Philly mom. But I’d sure love to be as thin as she is and move as fast. And for the record, I’m a Red Sox fan.”
She wasn’t the only one. Other women were falsely accused too. And that raises the real question: why?
Why did people feel they needed to know who she was? She didn’t commit a crime or use hateful language. She grabbed a baseball. That’s it.
So what exactly are we hoping for when we dig into someone’s life like this? Do we want her to lose her job? To be shunned by her community? To face financial ruin? All because of a baseball you can order on Amazon for nine bucks?
This is the slippery part of outrage culture. We confuse entertainment with justice. It feels good to pile on in the moment, but what about the person at the center of it? What if they’re not famous? What if they’re just someone with kids, a mortgage, and a boss who reads headlines?
Comedian Bill Burr once asked about cancel culture, “If a guy gets fired from a movie or TV gig, is he at least allowed to work at a grocery store? Or is that off-limits too?” That’s the point. Where do we draw the line? At what stage do we stop punishing people for being human, even when they make dumb choices?
My guess is Phillies Karen has already learned her lesson. She went viral in the worst possible way. Every time she goes to a game now, someone will whisper or point. That’s enough punishment for one ugly moment in the stands.
The bigger lesson isn’t about her. It’s about us. We don’t have to know everything about everyone. Not every awkward moment has to become a crusade. Sometimes, it’s okay to let things go.
Everybody makes mistakes. The real takeaway from Phillies Karen isn’t about outrage, it’s about empathy. If we gave each other the same grace we’d want for ourselves, the world would be a much easier place to live in.
